A common way for individuals to save for college is through the use of state-administered IRC section 529 plans or what the tax code refers to as qualified tuition programs. These plans come in two types: prepaid tuition plans and education savings plans, with the latter being discussed in this article. Education savings plans are a very advantaged way to save for qualified educational expenses. Contributions to the account may provide a state income tax deduction, its earnings grow tax-deferred, and if distributions are used for qualified higher education expenses, the earnings are not subject to income tax when distributed.

Donors have an unlimited amount that may be transferred directly to an educational institution for tuition under IRC section 2503(e). Contributions to a 529 plan will count toward a person’s lifetime exclusion amount, but annual gift tax exclusions ($18,000 for 2024) may be applied to avoid a taxable gift. If the aggregate amount of the contributions to the 529 plan exceeds the gift tax annual exclusion, the donor may elect on a timely filed gift tax return (Form 709) to treat the contribution as made ratably over the five-year period beginning with the calendar year the gift was made. This election permits the donor to borrow future gift tax annual exclusions to front-load contributions. In 2024, this election permits a donor to gift $90,000 ($18,000 × 5), or $180,000 if gift-splitting with their spouse.

Section 529 plans have their limitations too on the amounts that can be contributed. Limits are set by the states administering the plan. This is to prevent contributions in excess of those necessary to provide for the qualified higher education expenses of the beneficiary [see IRC section 529(b)(6)]. For example, in New York State, the aggregate maximum account balance per beneficiary is $520,000. Once a beneficiary’s aggregate account balance for all New York State 529 plans totals $520,000, contributions may no longer be made, but the earnings may continue to accrue past that limit.

Some individuals “superfund” 529 contributions for children and grandchildren when they are born by using the five-year election. When 18 years of compound growth is coupled with the use of qualified transfers made directly to the educational institution, it can lead to a situation in which the 529 plan is untapped or “overfunded.” When a 529 plan account has excess funds, which options are available to donors? The following discusses some of the more popular strategies.

Qualified Higher Education Expenses

Donors should review any eligible expenses in order to make sure they are capturing all of the expenses that the qualified transfers did not cover (e.g., books, supplies, equipment required for enrollment). Expenses for the purchase of computers, computer software, internet access, and related services (if used by the beneficiary enrolled in school), can be considered as well. Computer software designed for sports, games, or hobbies do not qualify, unless the expenses are predominantly educational in nature.

Educational institutions located outside the United States may qualify as well, so long as they participate in a student aid program administered by the U.S. Department of Education [see IRC section 529(e)(5)(B)]. Elementary and secondary schools can qualify as well under IRC section 529(c)(7), not to mention certain expenses for a registered apprenticeship program under IRC 529 section 529(c)(8). Each state has set their own requirements for qualified educational expenses, however, and it may not consider elementary school as a qualified expense. Each state’s rules should be considered before any distributions are made.

Some students may live off campus, and the 529 plan may cover housing expenses so long as they are attending college at least half-time. In addition, these off-campus housing expenses are limited to the allowance for room and board included in the school’s cost of attendance [see IRC section 529(e)(3)(B)(ii)(I)]. The cost of attendance can usually be obtained from the school’s website or bursar’s office.

Changing the Designated Beneficiary

Once all eligible expenses have been exhausted, it may make sense to consider changing the plan’s designated beneficiary. A 529 plan has an account owner and a designated beneficiary. The account owner generally requests distributions and is also entitled to select or change the designated beneficiary. When changing the account owner, there are no income, gift, or generation-skipping transfer (GST) tax implications. The account owner is akin to a trustee of a trust. Conversely, changing the designated beneficiary of the account may have gift, GST, and income tax considerations. Moreover, some states may not permit a change in the designated beneficiary if such change would cause all accounts for that beneficiary to exceed the permitted aggregate maximum account balance for that state’s plan. If the maximum aggregate balance for that state’s plan would be met, any additional amounts could go to another state’s plan, also recognizing those state balance limits as well. (Note: New York does not permit rollovers to other state plans.) Any change in the designated beneficiary can avoid adverse income and wealth transfer tax issues if the new beneficiary is a “member of the family” of the old beneficiary. A member of the family includes the following relations:

  • Spouse;
  • Son, daughter, stepchild, foster child, adopted child, or descendant of any;
  • Brother, sister, stepbrother, or step-sister;
  • Father or mother or ancestor of either the beneficiary or their spouse;
  • Stepfather or stepmother;
  • Son or daughter of a brother or sister;
  • Brother or sister of the father or mother;
  • Son-in-law, daughter-in-law, father-in-law, mother-in-law, brother-in-law, or sister-in-law;
  • The spouse of any individual above; and
  • First cousins.

Changing the designated beneficiary to anyone outside of this list would be deemed a non-qualified distribution from the 529 plan, and the earnings on the portion transferred may be subject to income tax as well as a 10% penalty [see IRC section 529(c)(3)(A)]. In addition to being cognizant from an income tax and penalty perspective of changing the beneficiary, there are also wealth transfer tax issues to consider. Gift and GST tax will not apply if the new designated beneficiary is assigned to the same generation as (or a higher generation than) the old beneficiary and a member of the family of the old beneficiary [see IRC section 529(c)(5)(B)]. If the new beneficiary is one or more generations below the old beneficiary, then the change is a taxable gift from the old beneficiary to the new beneficiary. And if the new beneficiary is two or more generations below the old beneficiary, GST tax would apply. It is important to note that there is nothing in the IRC or Treasury Regulations that precludes the old designated beneficiary from making a “five-year election” for the transfer to the new beneficiary.

Avoiding the 10% Additional Tax (Penalty)

Some designated beneficiaries may receive scholarships and thus not need all of the funds from the 529 plan to cover their educational expenses. Instead, they may just want the funds from the 529 plan to cover non-educational expenses. Distributions from the 529 plan may be made up to the amount of the scholarship amount without the imposition of the 10% penalty, but income taxes would apply to the earnings (see 2023 IRS Publication 970, p. 53). Any amount distributed in excess of the scholarship that is not used for qualified educational expenses is subject to both income taxes and a 10% penalty.

Special Rollover to Roth IRAs

Section 126 of the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 now provides an option to roll over remaining 529 balances to a Roth IRA for the designated beneficiary. These new provisions are effective for distributions after December 31, 2023. There are several requirements pursuant to the new subparagraph (E) under IRC section 529(c)(3). First, the qualified tuition program (529 plan) must have been maintained for the 15-year period ending on the date of such distribution. Second, these rollovers must also be a trustee-to-trustee transfer; there are no 60-day rollovers under this special roll-over. Third, amounts contributed into the 529 plan before the five-year period ending on the date of distribution cannot be considered. This may intend to preclude amounts that may have been contributed recently while the student was still attending college. In addition, there will be annual limitations on the amount of these special rollovers that apply the limitations under IRC section 219. Therefore, the beneficiary may roll over the lesser of their compensation earned for the year or the annual IRA contribution limit ($7,000 for 2024). Lastly, there is an aggregate $35,000 lifetime limit that may be rolled over from a 529 to a Roth IRA for the designated beneficiary.

Other Options

If no other option is possible, there are some other planning considerations related to unused 529 funds:

  • Use 529 plan funds to pay some or all of a student loan of the designated beneficiary or their sibling [see IRC section 529(c)(9)(A)]. The amount of distributions treated as qualified higher education expenses is limited to $10,000 per borrower during their lifetime to satisfy principal and/or interest of student loans—liquidate the account and pay income taxes and a 10% penalty. Note that income taxes and penalties are calculated only on the growth in the account, not the entire balance. And the income tax and penalty are paid by the distributee, which can be either the account owner or the beneficiary, ideally whoever is in a lower tax bracket.
  • Individuals that do not have family who they wish to pass the account to may consider using the funds for their own education.

For those that may have saved too much, there are strategies and options to consider for overfunded 529 plans. Designated beneficiaries and account owners are in a better position when they have more options and can discuss such strategies with their tax advisor. At this time, New York State has not updated section 695-b of the Education Law to include 529-to-Roth rollovers or distributions to cover student loan payments in their definition of a “qualified withdrawal.” State tax ramifications are very important when considering one’s options.

David M. Barral, CPA/PFS, CFP, MST, is a wealth advisor at Northern Trust in New York, N.Y.
James P. Hutchens, CPA, JD, LLM, is a wealth advisor at Northern Trust.