I read with interest the article titled “The Fraud Diamond: A 20-Year Retrospective” in the March/April 2024 CPA Journal. I also remember reading the original in 2004. Like then, I now still disagree with the authors that the fourth element promoted in this article is not a realistic element.

The article described a fourth point, “capability,” as the “personal traits” of an individual, along with the existing edges of the fraud triangle: pressure, opportunity, and rationalization.

While it is possible that personal traits have something to do with propensity towards committing fraud, in practice what we see is the following adage: “there are no bad people, just (mostly) bad situations.”

This generalization is held by many forensic accountants and fraud investigators. This is because it’s not mere capability that makes a fraudster—rather, it’s the situation that enables fraud, combined with the pressure to commit it.

I respectfully disagree with the authors, and I will continue to consider the fraud paradigm to be the fraud triangle.

Yigal M. Rechtman, CPA, CFE, CITP, CISM. Rechtman Consulting, Fort Lee, N.J.

The Authors Respond

We appreciate Yigal M. Rechtman’s response to our March/April 2024 article, “The Fraud Diamond: A 20-Year Retrospective,” and we welcome the opportunity to discuss and debate the merits of our model. If we understand correctly, Rechtman’s position is that capability is not a realistic element of fraud, as “there are no bad people, just (mostly) bad situations.” Furthermore, he asserts that capability does not make a fraudster, but rather the situation and pressure enable fraud. Overall, it seems that Rechtman’s position is that fraud risk is independent of the characteristics of the people who commit it.

We agree that there are bad situations and that pressure is a critical element of fraud, but the key contribution of the Fraud Diamond and its capability dimension is highlighting that people are not all the same and do not pose identical fraud risk. Rather, highly capable people are much more able to recognize and exploit bad situations and turn them into fraud. In other words, when people have a certain skill set and personality profile (high capability), fraud becomes more likely when bad situations (pressure and opportunity) are present. Thus, we assert that considering people is an essential component of fraud risk assessment, as opposed to viewing people as all the same or concluding that there are no bad people.

Research evidence underscores the importance of capability in two key ways (see our citations in Hermanson and Wolfe 2024). First, research finds that auditors using the Fraud Diamond model assess fraud risk higher than auditors using the Fraud Triangle model. Focusing auditors on capability affects their fraud risk judgments, providing evidence that capability matters to auditors. Second, research provides evidence that aspects of capability are positively related to fraud or the risk of misstatement. Again, the specific characteristics of the people matter.

Furthermore, there is research (Hermanson, Justice, Ramamoorti, and Riley, “Unique Characteristics of Predator Frauds,” Journal of Forensic Accounting Research, 2017, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. A31–A48) on “predators” (repeat offenders) and “situational fraudsters” (first-time offenders), suggesting that there are “bad people” like predators out there. Likewise, research finds that those with Dark Triad personalities (narcissism, Machiavellianism, and psychopathy) pose a greater risk of fraud (see citations in Hermanson and Wolfe 2024). Overall, the research literature highlights the importance of capability and unique aspects of individual people.

In this spirit, the thrust of our argument is the following: 1) people matter, and 2) we need more of the characteristics of the person in the fraud model—which is what the Fraud Diamond contributes. This view is consistent with prevailing research, and we fear that ignoring the unique nature of people will cause some high fraud-risk individuals to be overlooked.

Dana R. Hermanson. Kennesaw State University, Kennesaw, Georgia.
David T. Wolfe. The Global Fund, Geneva, Switzerland.