Ensuring Integrity
Highlights from the 19th Annual Baruch College Audit Conference
The conference began with a panel discussion moderated by Baruch College Professor Douglas Carmichael and featuring Sara Lord, chair, Auditing Standards Board; Anita Doutt, senior associate chief accountant, SEC Office of the Chief Accountant; and Barbara Vanich, chief auditor, PCAOB Office of the Chief Auditor. The panel discussed the research into critical audit matters (CAM) and whether these disclosures have met investors’ expectations so far. Vanich suggested that CAMs have not been as robust as some investors had hoped, and Lord expressed a sentiment that investors sought more consistency in CAMs without them becoming boilerplate.
ESG reporting was the subject of the second panel discussion between Susan Jones, director, global services center, audit methodology and implementation at KPMG LLP; and Soma Sinha, managing director, audit methodology and innovation I global lead–sustainability assurance methodology at Forvis Mazars. Sinha explained the double materiality assessment, which broadens the materiality concept beyond financial impact to include the impact on stakeholders, under the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) that will soon be effective for EU companies and non-EU subsidiaries.
This was followed by a panel on enforcement and litigation featuring Benton J. Campbell, general counsel, Deloitte; Claudius Modesti, partner, white collar defense and government investigations practice, Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP; and Sheldon L. Pollock, associate director, New York Regional Office, SEC Division of Enforcement; it was moderated by Douglas Carmichael. The panelists discussed trends in enforcement as evidenced by recent cases, while noting that the change in administration will likely result in changes to federal regulators’ agendas and priorities.
Digital assets were the subject of the afternoon’s first panel, moderated by Markus Veith, national leader of blockchain, digital assets, and web3solutions and partner-in-charge of Northeast financial institutions practice, Grant Thornton LLP. The panel featured Shelby Murphy, managing director, audit and assurance at Deloitte; and Jeff Rundlet, head of accounting strategy at Cryptio. “Digital assets” is very broad umbrella term that has complicated rulemaking. Veith also stressed the uncertainty of the regulatory environment for digital assets given the change of leadership at the SEC.
This was followed by a fireside chat with Wall Street Journal Reporter Jonathan Weil. Douglas Carmichael spoke with Weil about some of the noteworthy stories he has reported during his career, including the collapse of Enron and Lehman Brothers. The conference concluded with a panel discussion on AI featuring Brian Croteau, U.S. chief auditor, PricewaterhouseCoopers; Saker Ghani, chief digital officer, Citrin Cooperman; and Alessandro Peirano, seconded partner, KPMG. It was moderated by Bonnie Mann Falk, partner, Citrin Cooperman. The panel agreed that generative AI will be a disruptive technology with a fast pace of change that will lead to increased risks, especially if auditors do not understand how it is being applied and approach it without appropriate professional skepticism.
The keynote was delivered by PCAOB Chair Erica Williams. The following article presents her remarks, edited for clarity and length. The views expressed are her own, and not necessarily those of the PCAOB board members or staff.
* * *
Keynote–Fireside Chat with PCAOB Chair Erica Williams
Restoring integrity in public audits is quite literally why the PCAOB was created and what we have strived to achieve every day since. Let’s back up to 2002. When President George W. Bush signed the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, he referred to SOX as an answer to the call for greater corporate integrity after years of economic upheaval and reckless accounting scandals devastated far too many hardworking people and their families.
Furthermore, SOX charged the PCAOB with upholding the integrity of public audits. The PCAOB takes this charge and our mission to protect investors incredibly seriously. Our work is performed by around 950 employees across the country who work day in and day out to uphold the integrity of public audits.
Our staff have dedicated their careers to serving investors—hardworking people saving for a house, for their kids’ college funds, for retirement, for an emergency fund. The incredible PCAOB staff come to work every day to help protect people saving for a better life. Their talented efforts and expertise, combined with our mission to serve, create an incredible workplace. I could not be prouder to lead this organization, and I’m extraordinarily grateful for our staff’s work.
Progress on the Strategic Plan
The PCAOB works to uphold the integrity of public audits through our strategic plan, which outlines our goals: to modernize our rulemaking and standards, enhance our inspections, and strengthen our enforcement. This has been an incredible year, and I want to talk about the progress that the PCAOB has made on behalf of investors.
Under this board, the PCAOB has issued proposals for 10 standards setting and rulemaking projects and finalized 10 projects, including three in the last three weeks. With the recent adoption of the firm and engagement metrics and firm reporting projects, the board has taken more actions on standards setting and rulemaking this year than any year since 2003.
By adopting firm and engagement metrics, the board is making strides to provide investors with access to transparent, reliable, and comparable information that investors have been asking for since at least 2008, when the U.S. Department of Treasury’s Advisory Committee on the Auditing Profession, or ACAP, issued its report. The insights in the ACAP report, along with over a decade of the PCAOB staff’s regulatory experience, eventually led to a concept release in 2015.
PCAOB staff have been working on firm and engagement metrics for decades, and if the project is approved by the SEC, this rule would provide investors, audit committees, and other stakeholders with valuable information on firms and their engagements. For example, collectively, the information disclosed will provide a basis for investors to make more informed decisions when ratifying auditor appointments, electing board members, and allocating capital, and it will provide a basis for audit committees to make more informed decisions in retaining and monitoring auditors, providing them with information as they engage in a robust dialogue with their auditors.
Audit committees serve as a force multiplier in promoting audit quality for the benefit of investors. While we do not regulate audit committees, we do empower them with information. That is why the PCAOB is here—to help audit committee members be an effective voice on behalf of investors as they have those conversations regarding firm reporting and the PCAOB’s annual and special reporting requirements.
As with the firm and engagement metrics project, several of the over-arching themes and concepts in the firm reporting amendments were originally outlined in the ACAP report in 2008. To put it another way, the PCAOB is carrying forward recommendations that have been talked about for 16 years.
The amendments to this rule reflect lessons learned through years of work by the expert PCAOB staff, and, if approved by the SEC, would amend the annual and special reporting requirements, and facilitate the disclosure of more complete standardized and timely information by firms, such as enhanced fee, governance, and network information.
In November, the Board amended its registration rules to allow the automatic withdrawal of firms that fail to file annual reports and pay fees for two consecutive years. This change addresses the growing number of firms neglecting these obligations. Firm registration is a cornerstone of the PCAOB’s operations. If approved, this new amendment would ensure that investors, audit committees, and other stakeholders have the most up-to-date information on firms registered with the PCAOB.
At the same time, a project that was not ready for the Board’s consideration this year is the noncompliance with laws and regulations (NOCLAR) project. Since it was first proposed in June 2023, we’ve reached out to stakeholders for their feedback, including hosting a public roundtable in March of this year, and we reopened the comment period to hear from investors, firms, audit committees, and other stakeholders. We are now determining our next steps as we analyze comment letters received on the project, and responses to targeted inquiries of firms about their approach relating to noncompliance with laws and regulations or illegal acts.
In the meantime, our expert staff recently published staff guidance, which, among other things, reminds auditors of their obligations under existing PCAOB standards regarding illegal acts by a company and the audit of financial statements. While we have never been in a rush on this project, or any project, it should be pointed out that if our expert staff tells us a project is ready for the Board’s consideration, we would be doing investors a disservice by not putting it up for a vote.
While it is important that we get our agenda done—as far too many of the standards and rules need to be updated to adapt to the world around us—it is more important that we get it done right. That includes delivering modern quality standards and rules that reflect our investor protection mission in accordance with SOX.
Since I last spoke at Baruch in May, the SEC approved four of our projects: on quality control, AS 1000, technology assisted analysis, and rule 3502, which deals with contributory liability. Nearly all of those rules and standards had not been updated in decades. The existing standards the PCAOB adopted in 2003 were meant to be on an interim basis. What’s more, some of these standards at the time were already more than a decade old and largely unchanged when the PCAOB was created. Interim is not meant to be permanent or static and never revised or advanced forward in a rapidly changing world. Investors deserved better.
While the PCAOB has made significant progress, our work is not done. Part of that work requires robust economic analysis from the experts in our office of economic and risk analysis (OERA) to help us see around corners and anticipate the impact of our projects. OERA is recruiting for full-time research positions, including roles focused on economic analysis of new rules and standards and development of high quality, publishable academic research, to inform the PCAOB’s strategic initiatives.
Quality Control
I want to take a moment to highlight quality control or QC. QC systems lay the foundation for everything auditors do. In order to achieve a quality audit, an effective QC system must be in place, and if it’s lacking, investors are put at risk. We did not come to this new standard from a one-size-fits-all approach. We know that risks vary from firm to firm. The new standard requires all registered firms to identify their specific risk and design a QC system that includes policies and procedures to guard against those risks. As we created this new standard, we asked for public feedback. We read every single comment letter we receive, and we value the insights and feedback that we receive from the public.
For QC, one of the requirements is for firms that audit more than 100 issuers annually to establish an external oversight function, or EQCF. This is’ something that we’ve received extensive stakeholder input on over many years, going back again to the 2008 ACAP recommendation that firms appoint independent members with full voting power to firm boards or advisory boards that have meaningful governance responsibilities.
Measuring audit quality is complex and requires nuance, but part 1.A deficiencies are fundamental to an audit, and they are a critical piece of information that can be used in assessing the quality of an audit and providing a clearer picture of what went wrong.
Certain firms have acknowledged the limitations of internal QC functions led by non-independent employees and have lauded the benefits of independent review. What’s more, many large firms already have independent monitors or advisors, which goes to show that this requirement is not only doable, but is already being done in some firms. Ultimately, we believe the EQCF will help drive improvements in a firm’s QC system which would benefit investors, audit committees, and other stakeholders.
Our mission to protect investors is why, ahead of the effective dates for QC and other recently finalized standards like AS 1000, we’re committed to providing firms with resources to help them update their methodologies and train their staff; that includes a recently published practice aid that outlines the changes to the standard that may go beyond the provisions of other standard setters’ quality control standards. We also published a recorded staff presentation and a comparison document, along with a comprehensive document that provides an overview of the requirements of QC 1000 and staff guidance for firms about how to comply with the standard. Additionally, we recently created a knowledge check quiz for the new AS 1000 standard. Upon submitting responses, the tool provides participants with their results, including why an incorrect response was wrong.
Our goal in issuing these materials is to make sure firms are familiar with the changes, so auditors know what to do when the requirements become effective; but I want to be clear that while the PCAOB wants to be as helpful as we can, preparing for implementation is the firm’s responsibility.
Working Around the Globe
As we move forward with implementing our SEC-approved standards, as well as continuing to modernize the standards left on our agenda, we’re also enhancing our inspections program, which is one of the most important tools we have to keep investors protected.
The PCAOB is the only independent regulatory organization that inspects auditors of U.S. publicly traded companies across the globe. No other organization has this exact mission, and our more than 500 division of registration and inspection staff are the foremost experts in their field.
This marks the third year in a row that the PCAOB has inspected audit firms located in mainland China and Hong Kong since securing historic access in 2022, thanks to Congress’s leadership in passing the Holding Foreign Companies Accountable Act. The PCAOB is the only non-Chinese organization with the authority to inspect audit firms in China, and the only one that has been on the ground in China conducting inspections and taking testimony for investigations of audit firms.
The work that our inspectors do sets the bar for their profession. They work around the clock and around the globe. Their meticulous expert work highlights problems that demand attention as part of our inspection work. The PCAOB has an obligation to be accurate and precise in the way we communicate our inspection findings.
Tackling Audit Deficiencies
In recent years, PCAOB inspectors have found that audit deficiencies, particularly part 1.A deficiencies, are unacceptably high. Part 1.A findings are serious. It means the audit firm failed to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence to support its opinion, and audit opinions were signed without completing the audit work required to verify the accuracy of the financial statements.
Examples of part 1.A findings include things like failing to perform any procedures at all, to test revenue or the cost of inventory, as well as instances where the auditor did not identify and test any controls over long-lived assets and depreciation expense. These are serious violations that demand a response. Each part 1.A finding is described in our inspection reports, allowing the public to see for themselves the sorts of issues that we are finding when we inspect audit firms.
In 2023, we had part 1.A findings in 46% of the audits that we inspected. Simply put, in these audits, our inspectors found that auditors were not doing their jobs. To be clear, measuring audit quality is complex and requires nuance, but part 1.A deficiencies are fundamental to an audit, and they are a critical piece of information that can be used in assessing the quality of an audit and providing a clearer picture of what went wrong during the audit. While some have suggested that audit quality can be measured best by the number of issuer restatements, that a relatively low number of restatements translates to high audit quality, I respectfully disagree. A properly performed audit should identify errors so that they can be corrected before the financial statements are issued and prevent restatements. A poorly performed audit does not necessarily mean that the financial statements are flawed. Management’s processes and controls may very well have resulted in financial statements that are materially correct despite the auditor’s lack of diligence. Poor audits may miss errors that may never come to light, particularly if the same auditor continues to perform the audit year after year.
The risk that errors will not be caught and corrected is the risk that poor audits pose to investors. This is why we are focused on reporting part 1.A deficiencies and other information, to provide investors, audit committees, and other stakeholders with critical information in assessing the work of their audit firm.
The PCAOB is committed to educating the marketplace and evolving our inspection program. Our dedicated staff works tirelessly to provide critical information to investors, audit committees, and stakeholders as quickly as possible. I’m incredibly proud that this year, we released reports for annually inspected firms six months faster than last year and published nearly all triennial reports within six months of inspection completion. We also began to include new information about independence and other matters in our inspection reports for the first time, and we expanded the tools available on our website to make it easier to understand our inspection results.
Finally, we’re focused on a strong enforcement program because serious misconduct that puts investors at risk should have serious consequences. In 2023, we delivered historic sanctions, holding China-based firms accountable for violations, including falsifying audit reports, failing to maintain independence, improperly adopting the work of another accounting firm as their own, and sharing answers to tests on mandatory internal training courses. Last month we revoked a registration of a China-based firm for repeated violations of PCAOB rules and standards, and for failing to cooperate with an investigation into those violations.
Earlier this year, we announced a $25 million fine against KPMG Netherlands for violations of PCAOB rules and QC standards relating to exam cheating and misinforming investigators. The growth and breadth of exam cheating in this case were enabled by the firm’s failure to take appropriate steps to monitor, investigate, and identify the potential misconduct. The PCAOB does not, and will not, tolerate unethical behavior or any other behaviors that erode trust and threaten the investor confidence. Our system relies on the cases we investigate and ultimately decide to enforce; they involve complex and serious matters, from audit failures in cases involving financial statement fraud, to taking on client work that the firms cannot complete, and to altering work papers to not performing sufficient work before signing audit opinions.
All of these actions not only put audit quality in question, they put investors at risk, which is why, after examining the facts and circumstances of every case, this board has revoked firms’ registrations; barred individuals; required functional changes to firm supervisory structure; required firms to retain independent monitors to drive improvements and to best protect investors; and issued fines, including more than $35 million alone this year. All of these actions send a message loud and clear: If you put investors at risk, you will be held accountable.
When Congress established the PCAOB, it wisely directed that all enforcement penalties fund scholarships for accounting students. This year, we awarded a record number of scholarships, supporting a diverse group of future accountants—more than half are women, more than half are students of color, and many transferred from community colleges. A strong accounting and auditing profession is key to the future of investor protection.
Question & Answer Session
Paquita Davis-Friday: Over the past few years, the PCAOB has warned of a troubling trend in audit quality, with deficiency rates from inspections persistently being, in your words, “unacceptably high.” As you noted, firms are ultimately responsible for their own audit quality. But what role does the PCAOB play in driving audit quality improvements?
Erica Williams: I think it’s important to start with why investors, and really all participants in the capital markets, care about audit quality. Investors derive confidence in the capital markets, not just because there is an audit, but because there’s a presumption of a quality audit. Investors, creditors, and others who use financial statements draw confidence from the fact that the auditor did its work well and concluded that the financial statements were fairly presented in all material respects, that the financial position of the company is in conformity with GAAP, and that the financial statements are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error.
Investors derive confidence in the capital markets, not just because there is an audit, but because there’s a presumption of a quality audit.
When I say that deficiencies remain unacceptably high, I’m talking about these types of deficiencies where the auditor didn’t do sufficient work. That’s bad for investors. It’s bad for the capital markets. It’s bad for market price efficiency. And ultimately, it’s really bad for the auditing profession.
With every accounting scandal, we hear the same question, ‘Where were the auditors?’ Before I talk about the PCAOB and what we’re specifically doing on audit quality, I want to acknowledge that the ecosystem for quality audits have several drivers. The firms who are ultimately in control of audit quality, the investors who ratify the choice of the auditor and select the issuer’s board, the audit committees who oversee the audit, and the PCAOB.
The PCAOB is the only organization doing what we do in service of investors. Our inspections program is not just unique, but it is really the model for the world. More than half of our staff at the PCAOB serve in inspections, and they are quite literally on the front lines of audit quality.
I’ve had the privilege of observing our inspectors in the field, and their work is truly impressive. Led by experienced staff, our inspections go beyond assessment—they foster dialogue. When we identify significant deficiencies or quality control issues, we engage with firms throughout the remediation process, ensuring investors, audit committees, and financial statement users receive vital audit quality information.
Transparency remains a key focus. We’ve added new sections on independence in our inspection reports and introduced website tools with charts and graphs to help users compare data. We’re also releasing reports faster—six months earlier for larger firms this year. I’m incredibly proud of our staff for this achievement, and transparency remains a top priority for the board.
I also want to reference some of the other tools that we provide to help drive audit quality, including our staff spotlights—documents that describe our inspection findings. They talk about good practices that firms can use to help improve their work. We have doubled the number of spotlights that we’ve issued since 2021, and we are regularly providing the market with investor bulletins and advisories designed to keep investors informed about the PCAOB’s activities and observations.
We continue to engage with audit committees, and we want to make sure that they have the information they need to be able to hold firms accountable for audit quality. We want them to encourage firms to have a commitment not only to cost, but also to quality. Last year we engaged with more than 200 audit committee chairs, and we do that each year as part of our inspections. We have also been providing them with really specific questions that they should ask of their auditors.
I want to note that our office of the investor advocate, which was created under this board, recently published a bulletin that high-lights resources investors can use when they are engaging with audit committees concerning their independent auditors. Remediation is a powerful tool to help firms improve. The feedback we provide to the firms during remediation about their quality control systems gives them an opportunity to improve quality control, which can drive long-term improvements. Our staff recently published a new guidance document on remediation. I encourage audit firms to review that supplement and the resources that we’re providing.
Finally, I’ll talk a little bit more about standards setting and rulemaking. Over the years, we have retained those interim standards. Many of them are decades old, and we know that the audit profession hasn’t stood still, and so neither can the PCAOB. We have modernized the standards, and we still have some ways to go. One that I’ll mention again is QC 1000, because it brought needed updates to the quality control system, which is a main driver of audit quality.
We’ve recently adopted firm and engagement metrics and firm reporting which were based on 16 years’ worth of research recommendations from investors and experts. If they are approved by the SEC, they will provide extensive data and information to investors, audit committees, and other stakeholders.
I want to also note that the final way we’re trying to improve audit quality is through enforcement. We examine the facts and circumstances of every case, and we use enforcement to bring serious cases, and to make sure that we are imposing the appropriate relief, including revoking firms’ registrations, industry bars, and when practical, penalties. Together, these tools help the PCAOB contribute to improving audit quality and protecting investors.
Davis-Friday: Last year, the PCAOB adopted the new quality control standard, which will take effect next December. How is the PCAOB approaching the implementation date with regard to preparing firms for the upcoming changes?
Williams: We are very committed to making sure that we’re providing firms with the resources they need to appropriately implement standards. As the implementations dates approach, we have released a number of documents to help firms update their methodologies and train their staff.
I mentioned our staff guidance providing an overview of the requirements of the new QC standard and staff guidance for firms about how they can comply with the standard. We also recently published a practice aid that outlines the changes that may go beyond the provisions of other standards setters, and that aid is meant to assist firms in building upon their existing QC system to ultimately have a QC system that complies with the PCAOB standard as well as other standards.
It’s not just QC that we’re working on. We recently released a knowledge check quiz for AS 1000, and our goal is to make sure that firms are familiar with the changes, and that auditors know what to do when the requirements become effective.
Davis-Friday: I want to discuss an initiative that you’re working on with regard to the culture of audit firms. Can you tell us about the specific culture issues that concern you based on your observations? Are there aspects of work culture at firms you feel are promoting higher audit quality? We know that also the number of accounting students has declined at most universities which may be contributing to the staffing shortages at firms. Do you think that culture might play a role in that?
Williams: Culture, coupled with tone at the top, plays a critical role in how auditors carry out their work. Therefore, it does have an impact on audit quality. We launched a culture review as part of our annual inspections, and this initiative focuses on helping us better understand the relationship between audit firm culture and audit quality. That’s especially important in this time of rising deficiency rates.
When we think about culture at the PCAOB, we think about it in three categories. First, behaviors: what kind of behaviors do we see broadly reflected throughout the firm and modeled at the top? Second, decisions: how does the firm decide how to respond to certain behaviors? How is the firm leadership held accountable or rewarded for behaviors? Third, systems and structures: we’re looking at policies, procedures, performance management systems, and the code of conduct.
We have had a team of dedicated specialists in our inspections program who are focused on performing specific procedures that have the potential of identifying and assessing the unique aspects of firms, the cultures at each of the six U.S. global network firms, and the impact on the firm’s ability to consistently perform high quality audits. The team has performed more than 100 interviews with personnel across these global network firms. And they’re going through the information that they’ve received as a result of those interviews and other information. We look forward to discussing our findings soon.
We know that the talent pipeline has been a major issue affecting the auditing profession. There likely are a number of reasons that students are not choosing this career as much as they had in the past. And that may be affecting firms. One important point is that quality doesn’t walk through the door fully evolved. It has to be nurtured and developed. As we consider ways to increase the number of people who go into accounting, I think it’s important that we’re focused on how we can bring them in, develop and retain that talent, and expand the types of people who see accounting as a path for them.
Davis-Friday: Where do you stand with auditors’ use of AI for risk assessment and substantive testing purposes? Do you have any specific concerns?
Williams: Firms must have strong quality controls in place, no matter what technology they’re using. They need to make sure that they are complying with the PCAOB standards, whether it comes to AI or any other technology. While the use of AI specifically is not something that we’ve seen come to public company audits, we understand technology evolves rapidly. We have a project on our research agenda that is dedicated to studying technology. Specifically, our standards and emerging issues advisory group held meetings this year regarding AI and our investor advisory group did as well. Both of those meetings are available on our website. I encourage those who are watching to take a look as the markets evolve.
It is essential that we have innovation. It always has to be done with an eye towards making sure that investors are protected. No matter what the tools are, the responsibility to follow PCAOB standards are the same. One thing I would be remiss to leave out is that the PCAOB itself is working to be on the cutting edge of technology. Our offices of technology and economic and risk analysis have cultivated some of the world’s leading experts in AI, machine learning, and big data analysis. We don’t expect the firms to stand still, and we certainly need to adapt and evolve as well.
Davis-Friday: Do you have any challenges that you’re thinking about auditors facing in the current environment?
Williams: I think the biggest challenge is really complacency. We have seen an increase in part 1.A deficiencies. I’ve charged auditors to do better, and I think that the profession is working to do that. Investors expect us to continue to push.
Economists often say that prices are sticky, and once prices go up, it’s really hard to bring them down, even when economic conditions have changed. Similarly, with audit quality, once it drops, it takes some time to improve. But we are seeing an improvement in audit quality and our staff efforts, which have been extraordinary, that focus on making sure that we are driving audit quality to ensure investors are protected. And we’re going to continue to do that.
One thing that I would charge the profession to do is: avoid complacency. Now’s the time for us to push market-oriented approaches to improving quality through projects like our firm and engagement level metrics. I look forward to working with the profession to continue to do that.




























