Experienced CPAs considering a career move to academia may be curious about how to make that transition. There are alternatives to the traditional scholarly path that can meet the needs of many potential candidates. This article presents the authors’ diverse personal experiences to illuminate the options and provide a resource for those professionals considering an accounting doctorate degree.
***
“The decision to pursue a doctorate in accounting is a dramatic life change, especially if you have been working in a non-academic career for a number of years”
—Jason Bergner “Pursuing a Ph.D. in Accounting: Walking in with Your Eyes Open,” Journal of Accountancy, 2009
CPAs are leaving the accounting profession in droves, pointing to burnout, low pay, repetitive tasks, and the potential threat of artificial intelligence as factors for considering other career paths (See Mark Maurer, “Job Security Isn’t Enough to Keep Many Accountants from Quitting,” Wall Street Journal, 2023). CPAs may consider becoming accounting professors, bringing their experience into the classroom. Practitioners and faculty alike understand the benefits of incorporating faculty with first-hand professional experience into their accounting programs (Douglas M. Boyle, Brian W. Carpenter, and Dana R. Hermanson, “The Accounting Faculty Shortage: Causes and Contemporary Solutions,” Accounting Horizons, 2015, vol. 29, no. 2, pp. 245–264; Douglas M. Boyle, Brian W. Carpenter, Dana R. Hermanson, and Michael O. Mensah, “The Accounting Doctorate Shortage: Opportunities for Practitioners,” Strategic Finance, 2013, pp. 31–36).
Accountants who are considering an academic path may decide to pursue a doctoral degree to expand their career options, in line with the requirements of the Association to Advance Collegiate Schools of Business (AACSB) that a certain percentage of accounting faculty be classified as “scholarly academics” (i.e., have a terminal degree). In general, traditional accounting doctoral programs focus on preparing students for publishing in respected top-tier academic journals and employment at R1 institutions (https://tinyurl.com/rvnhbc55), whereas most nontraditional (i.e., flexible) programs emphasize publication in a broad range of academic and professional journals. An understanding of the differences and similarities, as well as the pros and cons, of the two pathways to a doctoral degree is crucial.
In this article, the authors draw from their personal experiences as well as the current literature to compare traditional and nontraditional doctoral accounting programs for those considering a doctoral degree for an academic career (Carol C. Bishop, Douglas M. Boyle, Richard R. Clune, and Dana R. Hermanson, “A Different Model for Doctoral Education in Accounting and Auditing: Student and Faculty Reflections,” Current Issues in Auditing, 2012, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. A1-A16; Margaret E. Knight, Douglas M. Boyle, John L. Eckroth, and Dana R. Hermanson, “US Research-Focused Nontraditional Doctoral Accounting Programs: A Status Update,” Journal of Accounting Education, 2022, vol. 58, pp. 1-12). Of the four authors, two obtained their doctoral degrees through traditional doctoral accounting PhD programs, and the other two completed nontraditional doctoral programs—one a PhD program for experienced professionals and the other a research-focused DBA program.
In addition, we offer advice from our combined experiences as doctoral students and include a list of resources for further reading and exploration. This article offers those considering a career in academia a better overall understanding of doctoral education. It helps dispel myths like “having a CPA means you’re qualified to teach” or “all professors do is teach” (James B. Biagi, “Don’t let These Myths Stand Between You and a Teaching Job,” Journal of Accountancy, 2017).
Accounting Doctoral Education
After deciding to pursue a doctorate in accounting, the next step is deciding whether a traditional accounting PhD program or a nontraditional doctoral program would best fit one’s goals. Traditional accounting PhD programs are full-time (often far in excess of 40 hours per week) with face-to-face classroom instruction. While these programs generally take four to five years to complete, tuition is usually waived, and students often work as teaching or research assistants in return for a stipend (Sarah Garven and Bailee Pennington, “Road Map to Applying for a Doctorate in Accounting,” Journal of Accountancy, 2018, vol. 226, no. 4, pp. 36–40). Many students in traditional PhD programs have recently completed their undergraduate or master’s degree and, therefore, have minimal professional experience, often two to four years. Generally, students in these programs are recruited by large research institutions with expectations for top-tier research (Christie M. Novak, “One CPA’s Experience in a Doctorate in Business Administration Program,” The CPA Journal, August/September 2021, pp. 40–43).
More flexible than traditional PhD programs, nontraditional doctoral programs are generally targeted to experienced professionals. They have the advantages of being flexible, taking fewer years to complete (three to four years), and allowing students to maintain some level of outside employment while in the program (Bishop et al. 2012). Nontraditional doctoral programs generally have a robust academic orientation or an applied research focus and offer either a Doctor of Business Administration (DBA) or a PhD in Business Administration. These programs usually encompass either a dissertation-only or a more comprehensive model with a formal accounting concentration along with the dissertation (Knight et al. 2022). As Knight et al. (2022) report, the options for this type of program are rapidly expanding along with the growth in the nontraditional market.
The distinctions between traditional and nontraditional doctoral programs are frequently blurred. While traditional PhD programs are highly research-intensive, many non-traditional programs offer a robust research curriculum. The focus of this article is on nontraditional programs that are research-oriented, as opposed to other program types that do not emphasize research [see Knight et al. (2022) for a listing of nontraditional programs that are research-focused]. Although the design of the two programs can vary significantly between institutions, the research techniques, curricula, and dissertation structure can be similar. Comprehensive exams and research dissertations are required for both program types. As far as job prospects are concerned, nontraditional doctoral graduates are prepared for executive positions, consulting roles, and careers in academia. Conversely, traditional PhD’s are focused on academic careers at universities where they engage in theoretical research, scholarly publishing, and teaching (Helen MacLennan, Anthony Piña, and Sean Gibbons, “Content Analysis of DBA and PhD Dissertations in Business,” Journal of Education for Business, 2018, vol. 93, no. 4, pp. 149–154; Anthony A. Piña, Helen L. MacLennan, Kenneth A. Moran, and Patrick F. Hafford, “The DBA vs. PhD in US Business and Management Programs: Different by Degrees?” Journal of Excellence in Business Education, 2016, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 6–19). (Note: All four authors accepted positions as tenure-track faculty at AACSB-accredited universities.)
Given that nontraditional programs may offer either a DBA or PhD degree, questions have arisen about the attractiveness of graduates from these programs due to the perception that the flexible nature of the curriculum represents a lower rigor. Indeed, results from a study by Boyle et al. (2015) indicate that accounting faculty from larger and doctoral-granting institutions are less supportive of flexible programs and perceive less value in recruiting practitioners into academia. A later study by Knight et al. (2022), however, found that numerous graduates from nontraditional programs have been highly successful in obtaining academic positions, being promoted, and publishing in notable academic, educational, and professional journals. Many traditional accounting doctoral programs focus on preparing students for publishing in top-tier academic journals, whereas numerous nontraditional programs emphasize publication in a broad range of both academic and professional journals (Knight et al. 2022). The difficulties encountered by graduates of nontraditional accounting doctoral programs when attempting to publish their work in leading accounting journals have been examined by Suzanne Lowensohn and Donald P. Samelson (“An Examination of Faculty Perceptions of Academic Journal Quality Within Five Specialized Areas of Accounting Research,” Issues in Accounting Education, 2006, vol. 21, no. 3, pp. 219–239) and Douglas M. Boyle, James F. Boyle, and Dana R. Hermanson (“The Intersection of Academia and Practice: Publishing in Leading US Accounting Organizations’ Journals,” Issues in Accounting Education, 2020, vol. 35, no. 2, pp. 1–17). In addition, some universities have converted their research-focused DBA programs to flexible PhD programs to emphasize their robust research concentration (e.g., Kennesaw State University).
To provide a clearer understanding of the differences between traditional and nontraditional doctoral programs, a side-by-side comparison is presented in Exhibit 1. This comparison is based on the authors’ firsthand experiences and analyses of both program types. As previously discussed, graduates from traditional programs are awarded PhDs in accounting, while graduates from nontraditional programs may hold either a PhD or a DBA. In general, nontraditional programs can be completed in a three-year timeframe as opposed to a four-year minimum for traditional programs. For many students, however, it may take longer than expected to obtain a doctorate due to factors such as procrastination, personal or financial circumstances, difficulties in conducting doctoral research, or advisor availability (and delays in feedback).
EXHIBIT 1
Characteristics of Nontraditional Versus Traditional Doctoral Programs

With the exception of a GMAT stipulation for traditional programs, entrance requirements are generally comparable between the two program types. Traditional programs routinely provide a full tuition waiver with conditions for teaching and research assistantships. Conversely, the cost for nontraditional programs can be quite high, although there are no teaching or research assistantship requirements. Cohort size can vary significantly, with nontraditional programs generally having a larger class size than traditional programs. Furthermore, student age, background, and employment status vary considerably between the two program types.
Pros, Cons, and Hurdles in Pursuing a Doctoral Program
This section discusses the pros and cons of the two program types and then expounds on the possible barriers that practitioners may face in their pursuit of a doctoral degree. Exhibit 1 illustrates that there are distinct advantages and drawbacks for each program type. The major benefits of traditional doctoral programs include a full tuition waiver, small cohort size, and a full-time, research-intensive focus for those who want to pursue a research-driven academic career. Conversely, non-traditional programs have the advantage of flexibility, with weekend residencies so that students can continue employment while in the program. These programs are generally geared towards individuals who possess considerable professional experience. Furthermore, flexible programs can usually be completed in a shorter timeframe, have no requirements for teaching or research assistantships, and offer a wider array of career options upon graduation. As far as entrance requirements, a non-traditional program does not require a GMAT score for admission.
Disadvantages of traditional programs include location requirements for a full-time program, the opportunity cost of a forfeited salary, a longer time to completion, teaching and research assistantship requirements, and GMAT requirements for admission. The drawbacks of non-traditional programs include tuition costs, limited financial assistance, a larger cohort size, and a requirement or preference that students hold a master’s degree. While flexible programs emphasize publication in a broad range of peer-reviewed academic journals, the program focus is not as research-intensive as traditional doctoral programs.
On the whole, the factors that practitioners find attractive in an academic career include schedule flexibility, work/life balance, and making a difference through teaching and guiding students. But there may be obstacles that practitioners should consider before undertaking a doctoral program (Douglas M. Boyle, Dana R. Hermanson, and Michael O. Mensah, “Addressing the Accounting and Auditing Faculty Shortage: Practitioners’ Perceptions of Academia,” Current Issues in Auditing, 2011, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. A70–A85; Boyle et al. 2013). In a survey by William A. Kerler III, Christopher D. Allport, Duane M. Brandon, and Jennifer A. Parlier (“From Practitioner to Professor,” The CPA Journal, 2022, vol. 92, no. 9/10, pp. 49–55), practitioners report that cost is the number one reason for not pursuing a doctoral degree in accounting. In this setting, costs encompass the tuition cost of a nontraditional doctoral program as well as the opportunity cost of the salary forfeited while enrolled in a traditional PhD program. In addition to the financial costs, it is important to realize that pursuing an accounting doctoral program will require a different set of skills than those used in practice. This means that making the transition into academia is drastically easier through proper preparation (Douglas Ayres, Kelsey R. Brasel, and James Duncan, “Making the Jump from Accounting Practice to Academia: Considerations for the Transition to a PhD Program,” The CPA Journal, 2016, vol. 86, no. 8, pp. 38–41). While the overall opportunity cost is a factor in deciding to pursue a doctoral degree, most traditional doctoral programs extend admission packages and scholarships that waive the total cost of tuition for students, and stipends are available for teaching or research assistant positions (Kerler et al. 2022).
On the other hand, students can remain employed at some level while enrolled in an AACSB-accredited nontraditional doctoral program. While a significant obstacle of nontraditional programs is the tuition cost, these programs can be completed in a shorter timeframe (i.e., generally, three to four years), allowing newly minted doctoral faculty members to recoup the tuition costs through higher doctoral salaries sooner. In the authors’ experiences, most students in nontraditional doctoral programs are experienced practitioners who have already transitioned into academia at the instructor level. Instructor positions offer added advantages when pursuing a doctoral education through schedule flexibility and teaching experience upon graduation. (From the authors’ experiences in nontraditional programs, doctoral students working as university instructors likely spend 35 hours per week at their job and 30 hours or more per week on doctoral coursework.) Moreover, university employment may offer partial tuition reimbursement to those faculty members who seek a terminal degree.
Relocation may present another hurdle for potential doctoral students, especially for those considering a traditional doctoral program which requires full-time attendance. Students in nontraditional programs generally commute to weekend residences that may occur once a month or two to three times each semester. In the same vein, the significant amount of time needed for doctoral education and the related impact on family obligations are important considerations, especially for those with children.
Academic research is another reason cited for the lack of interest in a doctoral degree. Both traditional and nontraditional doctoral programs train students in the requisite skills for conducting accounting research (Kerler et al. 2022). Traditional doctoral programs generally have higher expectations for research, allowing students to build a research portfolio before accepting academic positions. In a nontraditional program setting, the focus is on basic or applied research, with research training occurring through collaboration with experienced faculty in completing the dissertation.
Each author encountered different constraints in their decision to obtain a doctoral degree. Based on our combined experiences, we offer advice and suggestions and also recommend resources in the next section to assist others who may take the same path.
Advice and Recommended Resources
This section offers advice based on the authors’ combined experiences as successful doctoral students. This guidance includes identifying a doctoral program that fits one’s career goals and potential research interests; assessing a program’s location, requirements, culture, and results; preparing for sacrifices; enlisting a support team; and developing a plan to complete the program.
Match the Program to Your Career Goals
“I sought a PhD program whose faculty research interests were broad so that I could explore various research topics and methods. Some PhD programs are focused on specific research topics or methods. Because I wasn’t certain which topics and approaches I would be interested in, I focused on programs with a wide variety of topics and methods.”
(Daniel Street, author)
As tenure-track faculty, most institutions will expect candidates to be skilled and productive in both teaching and research. To determine if one will enjoy teaching, consider teaching as an adjunct (part-time) professor for a local college or as a guest lecturer for several classes at a university. As most practitioners have limited knowledge regarding academic research, contact accounting professors who can explain the research process and discuss how they determined their research areas of interest. Faculty members could also suggest research articles and literature reviews on various topics that may be of interest.
When choosing a doctoral program, consider the type of university that best meets one’s goals (research versus teaching orientation). This analysis includes the position one aspires to hold in their future academic career and the universities that meet those aspirations. Standard tenure-track faculty are expected to demonstrate performance in teaching, research, and service, leading to a permanent position (tenure). Clinical faculty are usually on contract and have a stronger commitment to teaching and service. They also perform less research than the standard track. While policies vary greatly by institution, some universities offer tenure for clinical faculty. A lecturer teaches in higher education institutions but is not eligible for tenure. Evaluate the differences between traditional and nontraditional programs to see which credentials are needed to fulfill program requirements.
A traditional doctoral program is research-oriented and designed for positions at research-focused institutions. In contrast, nontraditional doctoral graduates may seek university positions with either a balance between teaching and research or a teaching emphasis. A major factor in this decision is whether one can leave their career to attend a traditional program or needs to work while enrolled in a nontraditional doctoral program.
While the AACSB reports that the average faculty salary in 2021 for an assistant professor in accounting was $150,630 (“2021 Business School Data Guide,” AACSB, 2021), salaries are often significantly higher at more prominent research-intensive universities than at teaching-centered schools (Utilizing the AACSB Analytics Hub [https://www.aacsb.edu/tools/analytics-hub], the median faculty salary for third faculty rank [i.e., assistant professors] was $164,900 for 2023/24 [9-month academic year]). In addition, due to the shortage of new accounting doctoral candidates (Boyle et al. 2024), newly hired doctoral graduates are generally paid a higher salary than assistant professors who have remained at the same university for several years (Kerler et al. 2022).
Assess the Location, Culture, Requirements, and Outcomes
“Considering the options for an accounting doctoral degree, I would love to say that the only considerations were the program’s reputation and quality. The truth is that my initial focus was the location, program structure, and cost.”
(William Lyle, author)
In addition to internet searches, many academics can recommend programs with the best reputations and best fit with one’s interests. Another reliable source of information is former students from the doctoral programs under consideration. Examine the objectives, culture, and outcomes of each program: How long did it take students to graduate from the program? Where have recent graduates from the program secured positions? What are the relationship dynamics between students and faculty? What research topics and methods are utilized by the faculty in the doctoral program, and does this interest you? In addition, consider how the programs will fit within family and other obligations.
Be Prepared for Sacrifices (“Count the Cost”)
The doctoral journey is often challenging and filled with failure, disappointment, and exhaustion. There may be sacrifices, such as quitting your job, missing family events, having little time for friends, relocating, and the possibility of cultural or emotional challenges. For individuals receiving financial support from an employer or a doctoral program, what are the requirements for that support? Does it require a commitment to work for an employer for several years after graduation? Does it entail mandatory teaching requirements or service requirements (e.g., serving as a teaching or research assistant)?
The doctoral journey is often challenging and filled with failure, disappointment, and exhaustion. There may be sacrifices, such as quitting your job, missing family events, having little time for friends, relocating, and the possibility of cultural or emotional challenges.
Enlist a Support Team
“Traditional full-time Ph.D. programs are known for their rigorous and demanding nature, requiring significant sacrifices from the student and their family. My wife made the greatest sacrifice by leaving everything behind and accompanying me to a country with a completely different culture and language. I owe a great deal of my success in the program to her unwavering support.”
(Kourosh Amirkhani, author)
Family, friends, fellow students, and advisors can support doctoral candidates in overcoming setbacks and moving forward. This support team should be told that the demands of a doctoral program will keep candidates from their usual activities and that their support is valued. For those candidates in an academic setting, reach out to others whose advice is trusted and determine whether they can provide support. One author did not know about the financial assistance at their university for faculty pursuing a doctorate until after a conversation with the dean.
Make a Plan, Adapt and Overcome, Complete the Program
Success as a doctoral student requires grit, determination, and perseverance. Have a plan for how to get the coursework done. For a nontraditional program, be self-motivated and allot the days between residencies based on the size of each assignment and the time needed for reading research articles.
For both program types, stay motivated and consistent. Develop research ideas as soon as possible. Candidates need to conduct research-related tasks in much of the coursework, so get ahead by focusing on a research concept in the coursework requirements (i.e., students will get to pick the topic for a number of assignments). Carefully listen and respond to faculty feedback, especially those faculty with a successful history of graduating and placing doctoral students. When one gets to a dissertation, work on it continually and as much as possible. From the authors’ experience, it is not easy to pick up a project after putting it down for a while. Successfully managing the dissertation is crucial in completing a doctoral program:
“It is crucial to have a good dissertation committee, as they are your guides through the dissertation process. I referred to my dissertation committee as the ‘Dream Team’ as they went above and beyond the call of duty to help me reach my goal, and I am forever grateful for their direction, instruction, and friendship.”
(Valerie Simmons, author)
Resources
To assist readers’ assessment of accounting doctoral programs, Exhibit 2 provides a list of resources for further exploration. These resources include listings and rankings of accounting doctoral programs, scholarship and financial assistance opportunities (including funding provided by the Accounting Doctoral Scholars program), and other general information about accounting doctoral programs.
EXHIBIT 2
Recommended Resources

Current Trends and Challenges in Accounting Education
Accounting education is facing significant challenges. Recent reports indicate a substantial decline in student enrollment in many accounting programs, which may jeopardize the availability of university faculty positions as faculty lines are cut. Accounting department chairs across 20 universities echo this concern (James F. Boyle, Amanda S. Marcy, Douglas M. Boyle, and Dana R. Hermanson, “Accounting Chairs’ Perceptions of Current Challenges,” Issues in Accounting Education, 2024, vol. 39, no. 4, pp. 1-18), with notable declines in both student enrollment and accounting graduates. According to the AICPA’s 2023 Trends Report, the 2021/22 academic year saw a 7.8% decrease in the number of bachelor’s degrees awarded in accounting and a 6.4% decline in master’s degrees compared to the previous year. Furthermore, this downward trend is reflected in the number of CPA exam candidates, with unique exam takers decreasing from 72,271 in 2021 to 67,335 in 2022. If this trend persists, there may be long-term implications for the accounting profession, including talent shortages and reduced academic engagement (“2023 Trends Report,” AICPA, https://www.nysscpa.org/2023-trends).
Prior evidence indicates that faculty shortages are more pronounced at smaller, non-doctoral institutions than at research-intensive or upper-tier schools (Boyle et al. 2015), which may have implications for accounting doctoral program graduates. If research-intensive institutions have few open faculty positions, the competition for professorships at smaller universities could intensify and negatively affect job placement for graduates of non-traditional doctoral programs. This shift may cause some job seekers to accept adjunct (parttime) positions if they are unable to secure a full-time position they desire when entering the accounting education labor market. Although career prospects as a professor may be uncertain, accounting doctoral training offers valuable skills in many areas, including data analysis, research design, and communication; these skills are highly transferable to other career paths beyond accounting education.
More recent data may suggest a potential reversal of the declining trend in accounting enrollments. According to the National Student Clearinghouse Research Center, undergraduate accounting enrollment increased by 12% in fall 2024 compared to fall 2023, bringing student numbers closer to pre-pandemic levels (AICPA and CIMA, “Undergraduate Accounting Enrollment Rose 12% in Fall 2024,” 2025, https://tinyurl.com/mrxk3t49). It may only be one year of data, but this upward trend gives hope that ongoing efforts to revitalize interest in the accounting profession may yet yield positive results.
A Unique Opportunity
For CPAs tired of public practice, opportunities exist for accountants considering an academic career path. Despite the challenges facing accounting education, practitioners are in a unique position to inspire students to enter the accounting profession and contribute to the education of students through their real-world experience. The authors have drawn from their individual experiences to provide information, suggestions, and resources for those interested in pursuing a doctoral accounting program on their course to an academic career.




























