IN BRIEF

Public company auditing is a complex and challenging area of accounting practice. The following revisits the authors’ 2020 article that asked, “Where is public company auditing headed?” and evaluates how the challenges identified five years ago, as well as those that have emerged since then, like COVID-19 and artificial intelligence, continue to impact auditing today.

***

The authors’ 2020 article, “Where is Public Company Auditing Headed?” identified four key challenges facing the public company auditing profession: slow market growth, rigorous PCAOB inspections, low starting pay and intense working conditions, and the impact of emerging technologies (https://tinyurl.com/tdx3jbsd). Shortly after the article was published, the COVID-19 pandemic spread across the globe, greatly affecting the accounting profession. This article will re-examine these four key challenges from a post-pandemic perspective and provide updated implications for practitioners.

Overall, the professional environment has significantly changed over the past five years (see Exhibit 1). In terms of the four areas: first, there is no apparent major shift in longterm audit revenue growth. Second, PCAOB inspection activity initially dipped during the pandemic, but then increased considerably under new leadership. PCAOB inspections, standards setting, and enforcement all appear to have become more robust since 2020. With the new administration and its concerns about over-regulation, as well as the recent departure of the PCAOB chair, however, the future of the PCAOB is uncertain. Third, despite recent starting pay increases, firms have been facing an ongoing pipeline crisis that has caused many accounting profession stakeholders to take action. Accounting labor market conditions now appear to be rapidly changing and uncertain. Finally, the pandemic and technological advances helped to jumpstart widespread remote auditing, and some firms are now investing heavily in artificial intelligence (AI). Adapting to the current environment will require strong leadership from auditing firms and the broader profession.

EXHIBIT 1

Factors Affecting the Future of Public Company Auditing

Initial Pandemic Impacts

It is instructive to provide some context by briefly reviewing the initial impact of the pandemic on auditing before re-examining the four key challenges. Jason Ackerman wrote, “In one day, most of our offices became obsolete, the eight-hour workday was turned on its head, and the way we communicate and share information with clients completely changed … We learned how to manage our team remotely, host a Zoom meeting, and get our work done.” Ackerman predicted that many of these changes will be permanent: “there is no going backward” (“How COVID-19 Is Accelerating Change in CPA Firms,” The CPA Journal, October 2020, https://tinyurl.com/3muvyuru).

Charles Hylan and Marc Rosenberg summarized major changes to the accounting profession, based on insights from accounting firm managing partners (“The State of the Profession: The Impact of COVID-19,” The CPA Journal, January 2021, https://tinyurl.com/yc3ermnn). Among the key changes are the shift to virtual work, much greater use of technology, developing employees through virtual means, and effectively communicating online.

Kathleen Bakarich, Amanda Marcy, and Patrick O’Brien surveyed public accountants and found that CPAs perceive that their firms’ and coworkers’ support has declined due to the pandemic (“Pandemic Perceptions: Accounting Firms’ Organizational Support During COVID-19,” The CPA Journal, September 2021, https://tinyurl.com/55tceuss). One Big Four staff respondent described a disconnect between firm messaging and the reality of life at the engagement level: “Firm-wide messages have been centered on values and taking breaks when needed, but the engagement level communication is far different and much more concerned with getting the work done for the clients than taking care of firm employees.” Hila Fogel-Yaari and Kelly Gebhart discussed the impact of the pandemic in shifting much of the auditor’s work to remote and in altering the PCAOB’s oversight role, especially with respect to inspections (“The New Working World of the COVID-19 Pandemic,” The CPA Journal, March/April 2022, https://tinyurl.com/2scywe5d).

Overall, the articles above point to major changes in the auditing profession due to COVID-19. Issues such as remote work, declining support of employees, heavy workloads, and changes in PCAOB efforts have become quite apparent. The sections below will provide updated perspectives regarding slow growth in public company auditing, heavy PCAOB regulation, low starting pay and intense working conditions, and emerging technologies.

Slow Growth in Public Company Auditing

Prior to the pandemic, auditing revenues in the Big Four firms were growing slowly compared to other service lines, especially advisory services. As noted in the 2020 analysis, “according to The Wall Street Journal, ‘Since 2012, consulting and advisory revenue has grown 63%, compared with 11% for audit revenue’ (Michael Rapoport, “Big Four Accounting Firms’ Revenue Rises 10.4%, Strongest Growth in Years,” Dec. 14, 2018, https://tinyurl.com/2h6ed9hv).”

Audit Analytics reported continued slow US audit revenue growth from 2018 to 2022, with audit fees per million dollars of client revenue at a nine-year low in 2022 (“20-Year Review of Audit Fee Trends: 2003-2022,” https://www.auditanalytics.com/doc/2023_Audit_Fees_Report.pdf). Furthermore, the number of public companies in the Audit Analytics analysis dropped 9% from 2021, largely due to the decline of the Special Purpose Acquisition Company (SPAC) market. As a share of Big Four firms’ revenues, auditing continues to decline, although consulting is now facing some challenges as well (Mark Maurer, “Big Four Accounting Firms Pare Their Consultant Ranks in Postpandemic Reversal,” Wall Street Journal, July 18, 2023, https://tinyurl.com/5677h94r). Big Four firms have laid off thousands of workers, especially in advisory services (Mark Maurer and Alexander Saeedy, “Accounting Firms Overhired. Now Some Are Starting to Lay Off Partners,” Wall Street Journal, Dec.15, 2023, https://tinyurl.com/abzzk7xu). Many firms are pushing new hires’ start dates later, and many are offshoring work to India to help to manage their labor costs.

Overall, audit revenue growth rates do not appear to have improved in any meaningful way since before the pandemic, and auditing is a smaller slice of the revenue pie for the Big Four firms, currently about one-third of Big Four revenues (https://tinyurl.com/mr3h7jhj). Furthermore, it appears that firms’ interest in environmental, social, and governance (ESG) assurance services may be a result of relatively stagnant audit revenue growth (Alan Reinstein, Thomas Weirich, and Abraham Akresh, “Materiality for ESG Engagements,” The CPA Journal, October 2023, https://tinyurl.com/bd6djhpy; ESG News, “79% of Companies Now Obtain External Assurance Over Some ESG Metrics: KPMG,” Aug. 26, 2024, https://tinyurl.com/4c5c6aks). Nevertheless, given the pipeline challenge facing the profession (discussed below), it is unclear how effectively large firms could handle a significant influx of ESG work.

The PCAOB’s Regulatory Stance

PCAOB regulation, while historically quite heavy, initially appeared to ease somewhat during the pandemic. PCAOB inspection results for the large firms in 2020 (reports released in 2021) were much less negative than in prior years (Soyoung Ho, “PwC and Deloitte Get High PCAOB Inspection Marks as EY and KPMG Lag in Comparison,” Thomson Reuters, Nov. 5, 2021, https://tinyurl.com/2mucp3wb). Most notably, PwC had only a single audit with a deficiency in its 2020 inspection report, and Deloitte had only two audits with deficiencies.

This apparent softer regulatory outlook abruptly shifted when Erica Williams became chair of the PCAOB in the wake of internal strife and complaints that the PCAOB was protecting auditors instead of investors (Jean Eaglesham and Dave Michaels, “Auditor Watchdog Is Overhauled After SEC Report Cites Years of Dysfunction,” Wall Street Journal, July 9, 2021, https://tinyurl.com/hxd2a6yd). In 2022, PCAOB fines against accounting firms and individual auditors were the highest since its 2003 inception (Mark Maurer, “US Auditing Watchdog Tries to Remake Itself, But it Isn’t Easy,” Wall Street Journal, Aug. 17, 2023, https://tinyurl.com/2n29t9s3). In 2023, PCAOB enforcement was even more robust (Cornerstone Research, Public Company Accounting Over-sight Board (PCAOB) Enforcement Activity: 2023 Year in Review, 2024, https://tinyurl.com/y6n8pdws).

Williams explained the PCAOB’s new posture at a conference of investors: “This board is approaching enforcement with renewed vigilance … we intend to use every tool in our enforcement toolbox and impose significant sanctions, where appropriate, to ensure there are consequences for putting investors at risk and that bad actors are removed” (https://tinyurl.com/wvn7ka4x). In a 2023 op-ed, Williams took the auditing profession to task for its 40% deficiency rate in recent inspections, noting that the firms’ performance was “unacceptable” and cannot be attributed to the pandemic (“We Audit the Auditors, and We Found Trouble,” Wall Street Journal, July 23, 2023, https://tinyurl.com/aed22e42). The overall deficiency rate for annually inspected firms rose to 46% for 2023 inspections, with a “leveling off” of deficiencies at the Big Four firms (“Spotlight: Staff Update on 2023 Inspection Activities,” PCAOB, August 2024, https://tinyurl.com/yc7mksbm), before dipping slightly in 2024.

The PCAOB’s audit standards setting also shifted into high gear (Maurer 2023). In 2023 and 2024, the PCAOB issued proposals or standards related to noncompliance with laws and regulations, firm and engagement metrics, analytical procedures, confirmation, quality control, general audit responsibilities, and technology-assisted analysis (“Standard-Setting, Research, and Rule Making Projects,” PCAOB, https://tinyurl.com/yc5pa2ad). After an initial dip, PCAOB regulation has expanded overall since 2020.

Given the new administration in place in 2025, there is considerable speculation about the future tenor of the PCAOB. In July, PCAOB Chair Erica Williams resigned her position before the end of her appointed term, reportedly at the request of SEC Chair Paul Atkins (Soyoung Ho, “SEC Chief Atkins Ousts Williams as PCAOB Chair Amid Regulatory Shift,” Thomson Reuters, July 15, 2025, https://tinyurl.com/4c4b7m2s). Some wonder whether the PCAOB might even be merged into the SEC (Michael Cohn, “AICPA Prepares for Possible End of the PCAOB,” Accounting Today, Feb. 10, 2025, https://tinyurl.com/5hbbfmsa) or otherwise restructured. There is a great deal of uncertainty about the future regulation of public company auditing given these recent events.

Low Starting Pay and Intense Working Conditions

While large CPA firms have made efforts to increase starting pay to attract talent and offshore some work, the reality is that the pipeline problem in accounting worsened after 2020, although conditions now appear to be rapidly changing and somewhat uncertain. Starting pay in accounting increased during a time of very high inflation, thus dampening pay increases in real dollars. Furthermore, accounting salary increases have not kept pace with those in related professions (e.g., finance, logistics). According to Census Bureau data, inflation-adjusted accounting salaries for junior accountants have stalled (Lindsay Ellis and Paul Overberg, “Why No One’s Going into Accounting,” The Wall Street Journal, Oct. 7, 2023, https://tinyurl.com/5n6kmbmm). The Center for Audit Quality (CAQ) found that low starting salaries and the 150-hour requirement were key reasons non-accounting majors chose a different major over accounting (“Increasing Diversity in the Accounting Profession Pipeline: Challenges and Opportunities,” CAQ, July 2023, https://tinyurl.com/yc5ptpee).

In terms of working conditions, it appears that the shift toward more remote work has had mixed effects. On the positive side, many auditors have greater personal flexibility when doing some work from home; however, remote work creates challenges for onboarding and socializing new hires who do not have the same face-to-face experiences as prior generations of auditors (Gillian Barnes, Dana Hermanson, Margaret Knight, and Valerie Simmons, “How Remote Work Is Affecting the New Generation of Auditors and Audit Quality: Recent Research and its Implications,” Journal of Forensic and Investigative Accounting, January–June 2024, https://tinyurl.com/4njws7d5). While firms have recently struggled to attract new talent, those employees who remain with the firm may face even more daunting workloads. When asked about the balance of pay and work, a recent accounting graduate and aspiring musician is quoted as saying that public accounting “was pretty much a death sentence for my dreams” (Ellis and Overberg 2023).

With both low pay and intense working conditions presenting challenges, one effect was a widespread decline in the number of accounting majors, with many students pursuing data analytics, information systems, or finance. Likewise, the number of new candidates sitting for the Uniform CPA Examination dropped dramatically, from 48,000 in 2016 to just over 30,000 in 2022 (“2023 Trends: A Report on Accounting Education, the CPA Exam, and Public Accounting Firms’ Hiring of Recent Graduates,” AICPA, 2023, https://tinyurl.com/4pxtm82x). This pipeline crisis has caused many accounting profession stakeholders to take action, including the National Pipeline Advisory Group, which issued its report and recommendations in July 2024 (https://tinyurl.com/4r22p4tp). Its report includes six major recommendations: “Make the academic experience more engaging, address the time and cost of education, grow support for CPA Exam candidates, expand access for underrepresented groups, enhance the employee experience, and tell a more compelling story.” Encouragingly, the report directly addresses low starting pay in accounting, which had become a huge hurdle to attracting students into accounting. In 2025, there are signs of progress, as accounting enrollments increased 12% in 2024 (Bryan Strickland, “Report: Undergraduate Enrollment in Accounting on the Rise,” Journal of Accountancy, Feb. 5, 2025, https://tinyurl.com/bdh6b8zj). Changing labor market conditions in other fields, such as data analytics, information systems, and finance, may play a role in this shift.

Overall, it appears that the traditional model of “pay low starting salaries with long working hours” has collapsed in the recent market of employee power and the availability of many other employment options that may be more appealing than public accounting. This issue may go even deeper, as Generation Z appears to be much more focused on work-life balance than previous generations, making the public accounting workload even more of an issue today.

CPA firms’ initial responses to the pipeline issue focus on pay raises, perks, and offshoring, and it will be interesting to see if they ultimately invest in hiring enough people to meaningfully improve the workload and quality of life in public accounting. If these firms do not fully address their recent talent attraction and retention issues and make public accounting a more appealing career, they may be in serious trouble. Such personnel challenges also may serve to further restrict audit revenue growth if firms do not have the capacity to take on new clients.

Emerging Technologies

Public accounting was already moving rapidly into new technologies, but the pandemic seems to have greatly accelerated this move. The overnight shift to web-based video-conferencing and remote auditing in March 2020 has transformed the day-to-day work that auditors do. As noted above, this shift toward remote work has benefits and challenges (Barnes et al. 2024).

In addition to remote work, which is already here, another major technology issue is AI. The Big Four are investing billions of dollars in AI, and the long-term impacts on public company auditing could be quite significant, including affecting the nature and size of the auditing workforce (Chris Gaetano, “Decades of Data Fuel Big Four’s Generative AI,” Accounting Today, Aug. 9, 2023, https://tinyurl.com/yh4v25tj). The pyramid firm structure, the way auditors are trained and supervised, and the nature of audit output all could be altered, depending on how AI performs. For example, AI is expected to automate many tasks, streamline the audit, and produce significant cost savings (Jason Ackerman, “Artificial Intelligence May Be Coming Sooner Than Expected,” The CPA Journal, May/June 2023, https://tinyurl.com/4z546ayn). Such changes may affect the skills needed by entry-level staff, as well as the number of staff needed.

Implications

To summarize the discussion thus far: 1) there is no apparent major shift in long-term audit revenue growth; 2) PCAOB regulation dipped during the pandemic, then increased markedly under new leadership, but now faces an uncertain future; 3) accounting firms have faced a pipeline challenge exacerbated by low starting pay and intense working conditions, as well as the 150-hour requirement, but conditions and CPA requirements are changing rapidly; and 4) the pandemic has helped to jumpstart remote auditing, and some firms are making major investments in AI, which may have a significant impact on the future structure of the audit function.

What can be done to address these challenges? Regarding revenue growth, short of major economic or regulatory developments beyond auditors’ control, there is little to be done on this front, other than to pursue other revenue streams such as ESG assurance, carefully manage audit profitability, and mitigate any threats to audit quality as auditing becomes a smaller and smaller component of large firm revenues (Dana Hermanson, “How Consulting Services Could Kill Private Sector Auditing,” The CPA Journal, January 2009, https://tinyurl.com/3vxycaw4). Notably, EY’s attempt to split auditing and consulting into separate firms was not successful. It is possible that more effective personnel management or other strategies (such as AI and offshoring) would allow firms to be better prepared to take on additional audit or ESG work.

Addressing heightened PCAOB regulation will require focused efforts by auditing firms to understand and mitigate inspection findings, effectively comment on and adopt new auditing standards, and work to avoid enforcement actions. Firms will need to work effectively with the PCAOB and ensure that firm incentives and performance measures are consistent with meeting PCAOB expectations. As noted above, the future structure and posture of the PCAOB are uncertain at this point.

The accounting pipeline problem has affected the entire accounting profession, but the Big Four play a key role. If the firms want to secure and retain talent, starting pay must further increase and there must be significant improvement in public accounting working conditions (Christie Comunale, James Irving, and Joseph Trainor, “The Accounting Pipeline,” The CPA Journal, September/October 2023, https://tinyurl.com/5eaejv2d). Accounting cannot thrive as a college major if graduates make among the lowest salaries in the business school, may require an extra year of education (depending upon the state), and then work the longest hours. The profession would strongly benefit from recognizing that fixing the pipeline problem is going to be expensive and likely cannot be addressed through offshoring and AI alone.

In the authors’ opinion, options should include altering or eliminating the 150-hour requirement (Steven Mintz, William Miller, and Tara Shawver, “Rethinking the 150-Hour Requirement for CPA Licensure,” The CPA Journal, September/October 2023, https://tinyurl.com/y775pzu2) which is now well underway across the country, returning to overtime pay for audit associates, engaging more interns or other temporary personnel in busy season, and carefully managing the onboarding and socialization of new staff working remotely or in hybrid roles. Firms also should carefully consider both the advantages and disadvantages of significant offshoring.

AI usage and data analytics in auditing may be very appealing to students and may enhance interest in the auditing profession.

In September 2024, the AICPA and NASBA requested feedback on a proposal to provide an additional pathway to the CPA license, based on demonstrating certain competencies on the job in lieu of 30 additional credit hours of college courses (https://tinyurl.com/3krx-8sku). Thus, it appears that the 150-hour requirement will effectively go away, with one year of work supplanting additional formal education beyond the bachelor’s degree. Momentum in this direction increased greatly in 2025, with many states pursuing or passing such legislation (see “Tracking CPA Licensure Paths: Removing the 150-Hour-Rule Hurdle,” CFO Dive, April 14, 2025, https://tinyurl.com/yrezx7mn).

Addressing the pipeline problem also requires enhanced messaging about accounting careers, outreach to high school students, and innovations to the curriculum (Jerry Trapnell, Steven Mezzio, Michael Dugan, and Mark Dawkins, “Accounting Education Disrupted,” The CPA Journal, September/October 2023, https://tinyurl.com/2ea5hcys).

Finally, while the largest firms are making the greatest push into advanced analytics tools, such as AI, firms of all sizes should be working to enhance their analytics capabilities and to consider the impact on the audit process, staffing, training, and other areas. The authors believe that even after the hype fades, AI will ultimately have an important impact on the public company auditing profession. AI usage and data analytics in auditing may be very appealing to students and may enhance interest in the auditing profession.

The Challenges Continue

Since the authors’ 2020 analysis of the future of public company auditing, the pandemic, new PCAOB strategies and leadership, challenges in attracting people into accounting, and rapid shifts in technology have affected the profession. If anything, the challenges facing public company auditing today are more significant than in 2020, but with some signs in 2025 that major changes are underway. Slow growth, heavy regulation, low pay, long hours, the 150-hour requirement, changes to the CPA Exam, and slow change in accounting curricula all can serve to significantly dampen interest in accounting careers. Because auditing is the only function that necessarily requires a CPA, stagnation in auditing may also have important implications for the demand for CPA certification and the future prospects of CPA firms. There are nevertheless some encouraging signs. Profession-wide efforts to address the pipeline problem may help to alleviate the shortage of talent, and updated auditing standards and AI may offer important advances in the conduct of audits.

Readers are encouraged to consider the changing nature of the profession, including still-emerging developments such as private equity investments in accounting firms, possible changes to PCAOB oversight, and widespread revisions to the 150-hour requirement, as well as the implications offered. This is an important profession that warrants a collective effort to enhance its future.

Dana R. Hermanson, PhD, is the Dinos Eminent Scholar Chair and a professor at Kennesaw State University, Kennesaw, Ga.
Heather M. Hermanson, PhD, is a professor and director of the master of accounting program at Kennesaw State University, Kennesaw, Ga.
Susan D. Hermanson, PhD, is a professor and Forvis Mazars Faculty Fellow at the University of North Carolina at Wilmington.