IN BRIEF

The challenge of attracting students to the profession is not uniform across all areas of practice. This article presents the result of the authors’ project to bring students into real world professional settings by showing them “a day in the life” of a tax professional. This experiential project can enhance student awareness of employment options in the tax field, encourage informed career decisions, and help retain students in the accounting program.

***

For college students who have already selected accounting as a major or minor, the primary challenge is not whether the discipline is interesting, but how well they understand the career paths available to them and how those paths align with their professional goals and desired work-life balance. Although recent data indicate a modest rebound in accounting enrollments, the number of accounting degrees awarded remains below historical levels, suggesting that retaining students through the major and into the profession continues to be a concern (AICPA, Trends Report 2025, https://www.aicpa-cima.com/professional-insights/download/2025-trends-report).

Within accounting programs, student interest is not evenly distributed across practice areas. The declining interest in the profession has had disproportionate effects across fields, with specialized areas such as taxation experiencing sharper reductions in new entrants relative to audit (Megan Grady and Jon Durrant, “The Disproportionate Effects of Declining Interest Within Different Accounting Fields,” The CPA Journal, July/August 2025, https://tinyurl.com/mr4ctbdx). This uneven distribution suggests that students’ career decisions may be shaped less by aptitude or interest and more by familiarity, visibility, and perceived career narratives within the curriculum.

In addition to practitioners and faculty telling students about the many opportunities the accounting profession offers, students’ firsthand experiences can drive the point home. Experiential learning opportunities that place students directly in professional environments may offer a more effective way to support career exploration for students already committed to accounting. Workplace visits and shadowing experiences allow students to observe daily workflows, interact with professionals at different career stages, and gain insight into firm culture. Such exposure may be particularly valuable in addressing misconceptions about specialized fields and helping students make more informed career decisions. In addition to supporting career exploration for students already enrolled in accounting, such experiences may create opportunities for peer-to-peer learning, whereby participating students share their experiences with students in introductory accounting courses, helping early-year students better understand careers in taxation and the accounting profession more broadly.

This article describes an educational project created by the authors to take students out of the classroom to introduce them firsthand to the field of taxation. Engaging accounting students with the tax profession is important because they often have misconceptions about the field and may be predisposed to non-tax career options (Megan Hart, “Not Exciting? 4 Ways to Motivate and Engage Tax Students,” Journal of Accountancy, December 2022). By providing structured exposure to tax professionals and real work settings, this approach aims to help students better understand both the substance of tax practice and the range of roles available to accounting graduates. Although the focus is on taxation, this model could be adapted to support career exploration in other specializations as well.

Project Overview

The “A Day in the Life of a Tax Advisor” project is integrated into the accounting curriculum as a required component of the introductory taxation course. Students in the course range from sophomores to seniors, encompassing both accounting majors and minors.

The project’s requirements begin with students visiting a CPA firm during regularly scheduled class time in order to see firsthand the different responsibilities and various career paths available to tax professionals. Each site visit is designed to provide students with an overview of a CPA firm’s operations, focusing on the role of tax advisors. Specifically, the visits engage students in interactions designed to develop a deeper understanding of a tax advisor’s—

  • typical daily responsibilities,
  • interactions with clients and firm team members,
  • use of technology, and
  • opportunities for specialization within the tax field.

Afterwards, students are required to reflect on their visit and produce a three- to five-minute video summarizing key takeaways from their experience. Students are instructed to describe the activities they participated in, highlight aspects they found valuable or challenging, and provide recommendations for improving the experience. A standardized list of questions to address and a grading rubric are shared with students and used by the instructor to ensure clear expectations and fair and consistent assessment. This is a required class project which makes up 2% of the course grade.

Finally, students share their experiences in class and engage in a fifteen- to twenty-minute discussion, led by the instructor. During the in-class discussion, students often express surprise at how interesting and varied a tax practitioner’s day is. Because the site visits involve different firms, it is insightful to compare and contrast student experiences across firms. Students have noted differences across firms in terms of office size and culture, specialties offered, interactions with professionals, and the hands-on activities. Hearing about each other’s experiences helps students broaden their understanding of the roles that tax advisors play and makes the most of the time spent outside the classroom.

Structure of the Visit

The volunteer CPA firms are informed that the project’s goal is to provide students with an educational and engaging introduction to the tax profession. Firms are welcome to highlight their workplace culture and strengths, but they are asked to refrain from making the visit a firm-specific hiring initiative.

Structured guidelines for visits are provided to firms to ensure consistency across student experiences. The objectives communicated to firms include the following:

  • Summarize the responsibilities of a tax advisor and explain how advisors interact with clients and firm team members.
  • Describe the year-end tax planning process and explain the importance of proactive planning with clients.
  • Highlight the professional opportunities that accompany different areas of expertise in taxation, such as C-corporations, flow-through entities, transfer pricing, multi-jurisdictional, individuals, estates and trusts, and tax-exempt organizations.

Firms are given freedom to address the objectives however they deem best, and suggestions are provided to firms upon request. Firms typically respond by providing an office tour and a variety of other activities, including —

  • shadowing a staff or senior tax advisor to experience tax software in action, learn about day-to-day responsibilities, and engage in question-and-answer sessions;
  • a mock client year-end planning meeting;
  • a panel discussion featuring practitioners with various levels of experience and responsibility, and different areas of tax expertise; and
  • a reverse “Jeopardy!” game regarding CPA firm information, client service, and tax compliance.

Student Feedback

To assess how well the project’s learning objectives were achieved, student pre- and post-feedback was solicited. Early in the semester, students completed an anonymous in-class survey designed to assess their understanding—and perceptions—of the nature of a tax practitioner’s work. Students responded to eleven questions using a five-point Likert scale (Exhibit 1).

EXHIBIT 1

Pre- and Post- “A Day in the Life of a Tax Advisor” Student Anonymous Survey Data

Near the end of the semester, students again completed an anonymous in-class survey comprised of the same eleven questions as before, plus an additional, summative question and open-ended questions designed to solicit broader student feedback. To ensure anonymity and mitigate student concerns about how their views might affect their course grade, students submitted their end-of-semester surveys in sealed envelopes with assurance that the surveys would not be accessed until after final grades were assigned. Most of the students in the course were junior and senior accounting majors. Because the post-visit surveys were collected anonymously, the analysis is limited to aggregate results and does not permit examination of differences across student subgroups or firm characteristics.

A comparison of pre/post survey results indicates that students’ understanding and perceptions changed as a result of the project [Specifically, the results of paired sample t-tests indicate that pre- and post-responses differ (p < 0.01) for all questions (n = 71)]. Notably, students’ belief that tax is a dynamic profession that offers interesting work increased, and the perception that a tax advisor’s work is boring decreased. Students also showed an improved understanding that tax offers ample opportunities for advancement and a greater interest in pursuing an internship in tax. Students improved their understanding that tax is a profession that involves proactive and strategic client work and that the field provides opportunities to specialize in various areas of tax law.

Student responses to the open-ended questions further confirm the project’s effectiveness. Students indicated that they appreciated the firsthand look into the world of tax advisors and that they found the site visit to be an enjoyable alternative to the classroom. As one student put it: “[It was] much better to experience the actual environment versus being in the classroom.” Another stated: “It was extremely useful to go out and visit a firm and experience what a day of a tax advisor is like IN PERSON.” This sentiment was echoed by many others. For example, one student stated that the site visit was beneficial because one could see firsthand that “tax accountants don’t just sit at their desks all day” and another stated that “it was nice to see how alive and energetic the offices were.”

Students also noted that the experience helped provide a clearer picture of career paths in the tax profession (“It was nice to hear from people close to our age about what it is like to get a job in tax”), including a better understanding of how roles progress from intern all the way up to partner. Students also appreciated learning about the interplay between tax and advisory services. One student stated that it was beneficial “to see the path going from intern to associate to senior and how advisory begins to fit into the role.”

Beyond learning about technical aspects of the tax profession, student responses indicate that they valued the interpersonal benefit of connecting with practitioners who shared candid insights about their work. As one student put it: “Meeting with real tax advisors made me understand that the employees are approachable.” Another stated: “It is not as scary as it seems. Just meeting real people who do the job and seeing that they are the same as you, makes finding a job after class less stressful.” In one way or another, many students stated that they appreciated the opportunity to ask questions and “hear honest opinions” from those in practice.

Overall, students’ responses to open-ended questions collectively indicate that the project effectively enhanced students’ views of the tax profession, consistent with student responses presented in Exhibit 1.

CPA Firms Feedback

Participating CPA firms were invited to provide feedback through an anonymous online survey conducted via SurveyMonkey. When asked to weigh the pros and cons (from a personal perspective) of hosting students in the office versus visiting campus to speak in the classroom, practitioners overwhelmingly expressed preference for hosting students in their office. Using a five-point Likert scale, 40% of respondents indicated a strong preference for hosting students, 50% indicated a slight preference, and 10% were indifferent. Similarly, when asked to compare the alternatives from a student perspective, professionals responded that they believe student visits to the workplace are more beneficial than practitioner visits to the classroom; 30% ranked the site visit as significantly better, 40% ranked it slightly better, 20% ranked the alternatives equally beneficial, and 10% ranked practitioner visits to class as slightly better.

The survey also included open-ended questions to solicit practitioner feedback. As shown in Exhibit 2, practitioners consistently expressed a belief that the real-world exposure the project provides should help dispel myths about the tax profession and aid career decision-making. They emphasized that workplace dynamics cannot be replicated in the classroom. The opportunity to engage with multiple practitioners at different levels within the firm and to see firsthand a tax advisor’s daily responsibilities were noted as key advantages of the site visit. Practitioners believe that exposing students to aspects of the profession beyond tax return preparation, such as consulting and advisory work areas, should broaden students’ perspective on potential career paths and hopefully attract students to the tax profession.

EXHIBIT 2

Sample Practitioner Feedback: Is the “A Day in the Life of a Tax Advisor” project beneficial for students?

 Absolutely! This allows students to put what a career in accounting could look like for them ... brings it to life. I believe any knowledge gained from typical daily experience gives students more information to make an informed decision about their own career path. Yes, with this project, students can take a glance into what it feels like to work in this profession, and it tells them if they might like this profession or not. Yes —Practicing meeting professionals, seeing an office setting, interacting with multiple levels of employees. Yes — they get a better feel for what an office is like and a better hands-on idea of what it would be like in each office. I believe it helps them get a small glimpse into what someone in the tax world does. Being able to explain that it is not always just tax returns is very beneficial. I think students benefit from this activity because you are learning something that isn't as easily taught in the classroom. What you learn from the project can be helpful and informative to decisions a student wants to make about his or her career. Yes, I think this gives students a chance to understand what a tax accountant does on a daily basis and this helps them determine if this is something they would like to do. I think it's always beneficial for students to hear from professionals. It's good to get real-life examples and hear from people who are currently doing the job the students are interested in.

In addition to the benefits for students, practitioners appreciated the convenience site visits offer and noted that hosting students allows for interaction with a greater number and broader range of firm members (see Exhibit 3). Overall, practitioners believe that by stepping into a new environment students walk away with a more valuable learning experience.

EXHIBIT 3

Sample Practitioner Feedback: Please weigh the pros and cons of hosting students in your office versus visiting campus to speak in the classroom.

 Our staff loves having people come to our office as it’s easier on them and allows students to get a better feel [for] our work environment. It can be easier for professionals to participate when they’re already in the office, and we can access more professionals for different amounts of time. It’s also a way for students to get a full picture of the workspace and what it would be like to work at that office. I would prefer to host students in the office because I believe it gives a better insight to the overall day-to-day life of the job. There is only so much you can portray in a PowerPoint in the classroom. Being in the office kind of completes the picture. Being in the office helps to give students an idea of what the office environment is like and puts them more in the shoes of the professional.

Finally, practitioners acknowledge that office visits can better help them build rapport with students and establish their firm’s brand—even while respecting the authors’ request to not make the visit a firm-specific hiring initiative.

Site Visit Coordination and Logistics

Before the course begins, the instructor contacts CPA firms to explain the project’s learning objectives, solicit participation, and make arrangements for student visits. In order to minimize disruption to students’ normal daily schedules, firms within reasonably close proximity to campus are prioritized and the site visits are scheduled to occur during regular class time. The average duration of the on-site visit is approximately one hour and thirty minutes, with visits sometimes including breakfast or lunch provided by the firms. To minimize scheduling conflicts, the project can be scheduled on a Friday afternoon, which often aligns with the availability of upper-level accounting majors and reduces the need for students to miss other courses.

Students sign up for their preferred CPA firm using a Sign-up Genius link. Firms of various sizes—Big Four, regional, and local—are utilized in order to provide students a diverse range of professional experiences. Students who were already interning at a firm were encouraged, when feasible, to visit a different firm to broaden their exposure to varying firm cultures and practice environments.

Eight to fifteen students attend the site visit at each firm and the sign-ups are on a first-come, first-served basis. The class size is between fifteen to twenty-eight students each semester, with two sections of the course generally scheduled in the fall and one section in the spring. This results in the faculty member scheduling between two and six firm locations each semester. Although smaller group sizes at each firm have proven ideal, larger group sizes could be used if the number of firms is limited. Rather than interacting with students individually or in small groups, practitioners could interact with students in larger breakout groups, as many firms have suitable conference rooms that could support larger group sizes.

Students are encouraged to carpool, and it has been the authors’ experience that those who can provide transportation are happy to do so, ensuring that everyone can participate. Parking instructions are provided to students in advance of the visit and the cost of parking is reimbursed by either the firm or the university. Faculty should explore their travel policy for students at their university to inquire if additional paperwork or approvals are needed. Students bring small gifts, such as university swag, provided by the instructor or university to the firms for the practitioners as a thank you for their time and engagement.

Implementation Challenges and Recommendations

The largest challenge to implementing this project is securing CPA firms willing to host students. The authors have found that university career fair participants provide a sufficient number of firms for the project every year. Every invited firm has participated, with many firms requesting to participate annually.

During COVID-19 shutdowns, the project was adapted to a virtual format: Tax advisors created pre-recorded videos addressing different learning objectives. Students watched these videos before creating reflection videos. In subsequent years, the project evolved into live Zoom sessions with breakout rooms for each firm, allowing students to rotate and interact with practitioners. In this format, students rotated in groups through the breakout rooms for fifteen to twenty minutes at a time to interact with the practitioners. The faculty member coordinated the topics for each firm to discuss to ensure that all information was appropriately covered for the students. These virtual formats could be effective alternatives at larger institutions if coordinating in-person visits is not feasible.

The project date is set at the beginning of the semester and shared with students to minimize scheduling conflicts. Students who cannot attend due to illness or other conflict are required to complete an alternate research assignment on the role of tax advisors.

One potential improvement would be to have participating students present their experiences and reflections to students in introductory accounting courses. This would build their presentation skills while exposing undecided and early-year students to real-world experiences in tax, potentially increasing interest in the accounting major and careers in taxation. Anecdotally, some students who initially pursued accounting as a minor later continued into a Master of Accountancy (MAcc) program, suggesting the potential value of peer-to-peer sharing of these experiences.

Finally, the project facilitates professional networking by allowing students to interact directly with tax professionals and learn about career paths more extensively. Consistent with the project’s design, firms are asked to focus the visit on tax practice, professional roles, and day-to-day responsibilities rather than on firm-specific recruiting. Tax advisors typically share general contact information with students, and students are required to send thank-you emails following the experience. On occasion, these professional connections have led to internships or full-time employment; however, such outcomes are incidental to the project’s primary objective of providing tax-focused career exploration rather than serving as a hiring initiative.

To support retention within accounting programs and encourage informed career exploration, educators must help accounting majors better understand the range of professional opportunities available to them. In particular, students often have limited exposure to the nature of tax practice and may default to other specializations without fully understanding what a career in taxation entails. The “A Day in the Life of a Tax Advisor” project brings the tax profession to life. By stepping into real firms, students experience firsthand the energy, variety, and real-world impact of tax work. They meet practitioners, hear real stories, see actual workspaces, and begin to picture themselves in the practitioners’ roles. That kind of exposure is powerful and it stays with them beyond the classroom.

Practitioners are not just guest speakers, they are co-educators and ambassadors for the profession. Their engagement is essential. When students see what tax practitioners really do, they gain a deeper appreciation for the profession and a clearer vision of where they might fit.

Other Applications

While this project focuses on tax practitioners, the model is easily adaptable to other areas of accounting and holds promise as a dynamic tool to spark interest and inspire the next generation of CPAs. The model is intentionally flexible and relies on three components that translate across practice areas: structured workplace exposure, practitioner interaction focused on career pathways, and reflective follow-up by students. For example, similar visits could be arranged with audit professionals to help students better understand engagement workflows, team structures, and the progression from staff to manager. Advisory or consulting-focused visits could expose students to client problem-solving, data analytics, and interdisciplinary collaboration. In specialized areas such as forensic accounting, accounting information systems, or internal audit, workplace visits could help demystify roles that students may be less familiar with through traditional coursework alone.

Across these applications, framing the experience as career exploration rather than firm-specific recruiting remains critical. Brief, well-structured visits allow students to observe professional practice in context without the administrative burden of internships, making the model scalable for a wide range of institutions. Requiring students to reflect on the experience and engage in professional follow-up communications further reinforces transferable professional skills applicable across accounting disciplines.

Overall, these takeaways suggest that experiential projects of this nature can support broader student awareness of accounting career options, encourage informed specialization decisions, and contribute to retention within accounting programs.

Kaitlin Newkirk, MST, CPA, is an assistant professor of taxation and financial accounting at Xavier University, Cincinnati, Ohio.
David Randolph, PhD, CPA, is an associate professor of taxation and financial accounting at Xavier University, Cincinnati, Ohio.